Indonesia’s defense minister is blogging
I was shocked to find out through Shel Israel that Indonesia’s Minister of Defense, Juwono Sudarsono, is blogging*. His latest post discusses the challenge of governance:
For the past eighteen months, the most talked about issue in Indonesian policy circles has centered on governance as the key solution to Indonesia’s economic recovery. Governance -- both in officialdom, as well as in corporate as well as in civic society -- was the key to stabilizing the economy as macro economic indicators began to improve…
A previous post called for more humility in development planning:
Everyone at the [Consultative Group on Indonesia] meeting agreed that governance was the central issue. Somehow, during the presentations I began to muse that beyond the talk about boxes, charts, figures, time lines and target dates, I felt that there was a bit too much of linear technocracy thinking. Discussions about road "maps" and "architecture" of the recovery process need to consider the more fundamental human and cultural factors.
In essence, we need more thinking about "horticulture" than "architecture". However neat the plans on the drawing boards and however sophisticated the tools of development planning, it will be humans who will do the implementation on the ground. Team work and team spirit is more cultural than technocracy. Nurturing institutions require the appropriate implantation of seed, applying the right amount of water for plants and saps to grow, the right amount of sunlight to give light to nascent networks of cooperation among disparate groups. There will be hits and misses, and even social glitches and crashing of social gears along the way so long as 36 million Indonesians live below the poverty line, 10 million openly unemployed and 60 million receiving direct cash transfers until the end of 2006.
A strong dose of humility in development and recovery planning is needed by both donor agencies and Indonesian officials.
I was pleasantly surprised by the blog’s strong personal voice, and very much enjoyed that second post. It would be great if other government officials follow suit. (I wonder if he has seen our Aceh Diary?)
*Note: Yes, this might be a hoax. The blog was cited in the Jakarta Post, and has been well received by many Indonesian bloggers, but I was unable to find any mention on the Government’s site. My opinion is that it is legit. Update in comments below.
Comments (4)
Bookmark
E-mail
Facebook



Pablo,
Not sure what you mean by "shocked." Do you mind clarifying your reaction?
I was the one who wrote the article in the Jakarta Post and am quite sure it was genuine. I also corresponded with the Minister. He's a very accessible person.
The fact that it is not mentioned on the Government's site should not be grounds for suspicion of its authenticity, unless you take the Government website seriously, at which case we may have grounds to suspect the World Bank's research methods ;)
Posted by: Ong Hock Chuan | Jul 4, 2006 8:54:52 AM
Ong: Sure… by ‘shocked’ I meant that I was pleasantly surprised to see a Minister with a public blog discussing real policy matters. It is the first of its kind that I have seen, ie: Minister-level and developing country. More than that, I felt that the blog has a great voice – these sort of blogs/sites are normally bogged down by dreary and safe bureaucratic language that have been screened by a press secretary.
As to the authenticity, I said above that I think that it is legit. However, it is a frequent issue with blogs that it is tough to make sure the authors are who they say they are. There are several fake blogs out there that have tricked lots and lots of people – especially regarding public officials or celebrities. For example, when we first started this blog we delayed launch until we could get a World Bank domain – we felt that was important for readers to take us seriously from the start.
(Oh, and the problem is even worse with blog comments. It is almost impossible to tell if someone is who they are claiming to be if they are trying to trick you.)
Posted by: Pablo Halkyard | Jul 4, 2006 11:29:16 AM
Ok, so it seems to be entirely legit.
Here is the web designed that built the site:
http://www.vikingkarwur.com/portfolio/2006/06/juwono_sudarsono.php
And the WSJ's Jeremy Wagstaff says that one of the Minister's sons is doing the day-to-day site maintenance:
http://www.loosewireblog.com/2006/07/the_defense_min.html
And I agree with Jeremy that it is great that the Minister is also responding to questions and comments. Though my guess is that he is still under the radar - lets see what happens when more of Indonesia sees that this is live.
Posted by: Pablo Halkyard | Jul 4, 2006 11:39:50 AM
I certainly am pleased to know that a minister of Indonesian cabinet has posed his more concrete ideas even on a blog.
Posted by: anee rachim | Oct 5, 2006 12:04:29 AM